Year |
Charles Sutton Medal |
Runner-up* |
Third Place** |
| 2025 | Ed Richards (299 votes) | Marcus Bontempelli (286) | Tom Liberatore (279) |
| 2024 | Marcus Bontempelli (314) | Bailey Dale/Adam Treloar (245) | |
| 2023 | Marcus Bontempelli (342) | Tom Liberatore (278) | Ed Richards (193) |
| 2022 | Josh Dunkley (231) | Tom Liberatore (211) | Aaron Naughton (180) |
| 2021 | Marcus Bontempelli (353) | Jack Macrae (296) | Tom Liberatore (291) |
| 2020 | Caleb Daniel (205) | Marcus Bontempelli (195) | Tom Liberatore (160) |
| 2019 | Marcus Bontempelli (299) | Josh Dunkley (270) | Jack Macrae (268) |
| 2018 | Lachie Hunter (191) | Jack Macrae (190) | Marcus Bontempelli (154) |
| 2017 | Marcus Bontempelli (185) | Jason Johannisen (184) | Jack Macrae (155) |
| 2016 | Marcus Bontempelli (319) | Dale Morris (248) | Lachie Hunter (246) |
| 2015 | Easton Wood (268) | Robert Murphy (229) | Marcus Bontempelli (226) |
| 2014 | Tom Liberatore (235) | Jack Macrae (168) | Ryan Griffen (154) |
| 2013 | Ryan Griffen (273) | Tom Liberatore (242) | Will Minson (184) |
| 2012 | Matthew Boyd (168) | Ryan Griffen (150) | Liam Picken (110) |
| 2011 | Matthew Boyd (140) | Robert Murphy (130) | Ryan Griffen (99) |
| 2010 | Ryan Griffen (137) | Daniel Cross (126) | Daniel Giansiracusa (113) |
| 2009 | Matthew Boyd (154) | Daniel Cross (145) | Dale Morris (133) |
| 2008 | Daniel Cross (191) | Adam Cooney (167) | Matthew Boyd (163) |
| 2007 | Brian Lake (121) | Brad Johnson (100) | Scott West (98) |
| 2006 | Brad Johnson (197) | Scott West (162) | Daniel Cross (158) |
| 2005 | Scott West (160) | Daniel Cross (138) | Lindsay Gilbee (125) |
| 2004 | Scott West (139) | Luke Darcy (126) | Brad Johnson (119) |
| 2003 | Scott West (157) | Brad Johnson (117) | Rohan Smith (108) |
| 2002 | Brad Johnson (185) | Luke Darcy (183) | Nathan Brown (182) |
| 2001 | Luke Darcy (168) | Scott West (162) | Chris Grant (139) |
| 2000 | Scott West (216) | Nathan Brown (175) | Brad Johnson (161) |
| 1999 | Brad Johnson (171) | Chris Grant (162) | Rohan Smith/Tony Liberatore (140) |
| 1998 | Scott West (223) | Chris Grant (200) | Jose Romero (182) |
| 1997 | Scott West (35) | Chris Grant (32) | Tony Liberatore (31) |
| 1996 | Chris Grant/Jose Romero (33) | Rohan Smith (17) | |
| 1995 | Scott West (29) | Tony Liberatore (28) | Leon Cameron (26) |
| 1994 | Chris Grant (283) | Steve Kretiuk (276) | Tony Liberatore (260) |
| 1993 | Leon Cameron (222) | Tony Liberatore (220) | Scott Wynd (219) |
| 1992 | Scott Wynd (307) | Tony Liberatore (299) | Simon Atkins (297) |
| 1991 | Tony Liberatore (268) | Scott Wynd (256) | Simon Atkins (242) |
| 1990 | Peter Foster (132) | Tony McGuinness (127) | Terry Wallace (126) |
| 1989 | Terry Wallace | Doug Hawkins | Stephen Wallis |
| 1988 | Terry Wallace (37) | Brian Royal (37) | Peter Foster (34) |
| 1987 | Tony McGuinness (240) | Peter Foster (204) | Stephen Wallis (156) |
| 1986 | Brad Hardie (167) | Andrew Purser (166) | Rick Kennedy (142) |
| 1985 | Doug Hawkins (233) | Stephen Wallis (207) | Brian Royal (199) |
| 1984 | Andrew Purser (178) | Doug Hawkins (177) | Brian Royal (152) |
| 1983 | Brian Royal (179) | Brian Cordy (153) | Andrew Purser (146) |
| 1982 | Ian Dunstan (75) | Doug Hawkins (64) | Bill Berry (57) |
| 1981 | Ian Dunstan (135) | Mick Egan (131) | Ian Hampshire (95) |
| 1980 | Kelvin Templeton (209) | Ian Hampshire (115) | Ian Dunstan (98) |
| 1979 | Ian Dunstan (83) | Mick Egan (58) | Doug Hawkins (52) |
| 1978 | Kelvin Templeton (84) | Gary Dempsey (76) | Geoff Jennings (70) |
| 1977 | Gary Dempsey (101) | Geoff Jennings (64) | Bernie Quinlan (56) |
| 1976 | Gary Dempsey (139) | Terry Wheeler (89) | Geoff Jennings (79) |
| 1975 | Gary Dempsey (267) | Peter Featherby (98) | Bernie Quinlan (82) |
| 1974 | Gary Dempsey (90) | Stephen Power (59) | Ray Huppatz (52) |
| 1973 | Gary Dempsey (173) | Adrian Gallagher (85) | Bernie Quinlan (80) |
| 1972 | Peter Welsh (120) | Gary Dempsey (111) | George Bissett (84) |
| 1971 | David Thorpe (218) | Gary Dempsey (124) | David Darcy (101) |
| 1970 | Gary Dempsey (106) | Gordon Casey (76) | Stuart Magee (42) |
| 1969 | George Bissett (104) | David Thorpe (46) | David Darcy (30) |
| 1968 | David Thorpe | John Schultz | Stuart Magee |
| 1967 | John Jillard | Ken Greenwood | Graeme Chalmers |
| 1966 | John Schultz | Don McKenzie | John Jillard |
| 1965 | John Schultz | John Jillard | Merv Hobbs |
| 1964 | John Schultz | David Darcy | Ted Whitten Sr. |
| 1963 | Ray Walker | John Jillard | |
| 1962 | John Schultz | John Jillard | |
| 1961 | Ted Whitten | Charlie Evans | |
| 1960 | John Schultz | Ted Whitten | Cameron McDonald |
| 1959 | Ted Whitten Sr. | John Schultz | |
| 1958 | Ted Whitten Sr. | Don Ross | John Schultz |
| 1957 | Ted Whitten Sr. | ||
| 1956 | Don Ross | ||
| 1955 | Peter Box | ||
| 1954 | Ted Whitten Sr. | ||
| 1953 | Harvey Stevens | ||
| 1952 | Jack Collins | ||
| 1951 | Jack Collins | ||
| 1950 | Charlie Sutton | ||
| 1949 | Wally Donald | ||
| 1948 | Harry Hickey | ||
| 1947 | Joe Ryan | ||
| 1946 | Joe Ryan | ||
| 1945 | Harry Hickey | ||
| 1944 | Arthur Olliver | ||
| 1943 | Allan Collins | ||
| 1942 | Ted Ellis | ||
| 1941 | Arthur Olliver/Norman Ware | ||
| 1940 | Norman Ware | ||
| 1939 | Harry Hickey | ||
| 1938 | Norman Ware | ||
| 1937 | Norman Ware | ||
| 1936 | Alby Morrison | ||
| 1935 | George Bennett | ||
| 1934 | Norman Ware | ||
| 1933 | Alby Morrison | ||
| 1932 | Ivan McAlpine | ||
| 1931 | Allan Hopkins | ||
| 1930 | Ivan McAlpine | ||
| 1929 | Bill Russ | ||
| 1928 | Alby Outen | ||
| 1927 | Ivan McAlpine |
*Renamed the Doug Hawkins Medal at the conclusion of 2011
** Renamed the Gary Dempsey Medal at the conclusion of 2011
